I am sure that the title of this post caught your attention. Well, it was supposed to. Last year Amnesty Spain published a report about videogame violence that was so bad that it was laughable. Disclaimer: I didn't laugh because they messed with my games, too. Anyway, it seems that it's an Spanish tradtion to publish reports about videogames on Christmas. Now it's the turn of the Minor Defense League of Madrid, that published a
website with plenty of information about games, geared towards parents.
rPlease do not get me wrong. They did a good job, this is exactly what parents need: a guide showing which games are suitable for which ages and stressing the fact that many games are not meant to be played by minors. The
guide (pdf, Spanish only) is well-written (by people who obviously know about the games, which is great). Along with the guide, there is a research report called "Videojuegos, menores y responsabilidad de los padres" (Videogames, minors and parent's responsibility). The report is well-done and clear. Basically, it's the data gathered through 4.000 forms completed by children between 10 and 17. That's the first thing that it's a bit troubling. Many children younger than 10 years old are indeed minors and play videogames, but they are not included on the sample. Since the report is called "minors" and explores issues of game and violence, it's really easy to assume that a 6 year old player would be included. So, the sample is certainly geared towards "older" children, a fact that -unsurprisingly- hasn't been picked up by the press. Here's a google cache link to a El Pais
article that keeps talking about "children" rather than "minors", which distorts quite much the results of the research.
rBut this is just a minor (no pun intended) comment. There is a totally unexcusable aspect of this report that trashes completely all the goodwill that was behind this project. The report concludes that "20% of minors admit playing videogames where children, elders or pregnant women are damaged, tortured or killed". I am sorry, but I have no option than to think that the phrasing of this conclusion is done in bad faith. Ok, please, tell me, how many videogames available today in the market feature pregnant women? The only one that I can think top of my mind is Little Big Adventure, a game that is more than 5 years old. And The Sims 2. Any other popular games that you know? (please let me know). I am positive that we can hardly find more than a few examples. Ok, within those potential examples, on how many of them can the player torture the pregnant woman? The phrasing of that section of the report is equivalent to ask children "Have you recently played any games where your character jumps and/or worships Adolf Hitler?"
rI am sad to say this, but at least the report is overall well-done. Still, these unbelievably biased elements make me really, really sad.